100% Kiwi owned & operated

All orders ship from our NZ warehouse

100,000+ Verified Customer Reviews • 98% Positive Feedback
★★★★★

Eyebrow Pencils

(11 products)
View as

Eyebrow Pencils for Shaping, Filling & Definition:

Shape sparse areas, define arches and build natural-looking brows with this collection of eyebrow pencils from brands including Shu Uemura, Guerlain, MCoBeauty, Maybelline, KISS ME Heavy Rotation, Yves Saint Laurent and THREE. The range includes traditional pencils, retractable designs, powder pencils and refill formats, with different tip shapes suited to both fine strokes and broader filling.

Precision Brow Pencils:

For detailed definition, look for eyebrow pencils designed to create controlled, hair-like strokes. Shu Uemura Hard Formula Hard 9 uses a firm powder-wax texture that activates against the natural oils of the brow, allowing colour to be built gradually while maintaining a soft, powdery appearance.

Maybelline Tattoo Brow in Deep Brown features an ultra-fine tip for filling gaps and defining the brow shape, along with a waterproof formula designed to resist smudging and fading. Guerlain’s eyebrow pencil uses a velvety texture intended for precise shaping and filling sparse areas.

Retractable & Dual-Ended Brow Pencils:

MCoBeauty XtendBrows Shape & Sculpt pencils are available in Light/Medium and Medium/Dark shades. Their ultra-thin triangular tip can create lighter strokes or fill larger gaps, while the retractable design and built-in spoolie make it easy to shape, apply and blend with one tool.

KISS ME Heavy Rotation combines an ultra-flat oval pencil tip with a spiral eyebrow brush. The shape allows both fine and thicker lines, while its long-wearing formula is designed to resist sweat, sebum and rubbing.

Choosing an Eyebrow Pencil:

Choose an ultra-fine tip when you want individual-looking strokes and detailed arch definition. Triangular or flat oval tips provide more flexibility for switching between precise lines and filling larger areas, while powder-style formulas can create a softer finish.

The collection also includes lighter and deeper shades such as Stone Gray, Light Brown, Deep Brown and Light, plus a THREE Lasting Eyebrow Pencil refill with a flat oval tip for existing compatible brow pencils.