100% Kiwi owned & operated

All orders ship from our NZ warehouse

100,000+ Verified Customer Reviews • 98% Positive Feedback
★★★★★

Brow Pencils

(74 products)
View as

Brow Pencils for Natural Definition & Precision Shaping:

Shape, fill and define your brows with eyebrow pencils designed for everything from soft, natural-looking enhancement to more precisely sculpted arches. This collection brings together brow pencils from brands including LA Colors, LA Girl, Benefit, Bobbi Brown, MAC, Fenty Beauty, MCoBeauty, Maybelline, Shu Uemura, Guerlain and Yves Saint Laurent, with a variety of pencil formats, tip shapes and brow shades.

Ultra-Fine & Precision Brow Pencils:

For filling sparse areas with fine, hair-like strokes, look for ultra-fine and precision-tip eyebrow pencils. Benefit Precisely My Brow uses an ultra-fine twist-up tip with blendable colour, while Fenty Beauty Brow MVP combines an ultra-fine retractable pencil with a built-in styling brush. MAC Pro Brow Definer options feature a 1 mm tip for detailed application.

Brow Pencils with Spoolies & Shaping Tools:

Several pencils combine colour with an integrated brow brush or spoolie, allowing you to fill, blend and groom with one product. LA Colors On Point Brow Pencil creates a matte finish and includes a brush end for blending and taming brows. MCoBeauty XtendBrows uses an ultra-thin triangular tip alongside an in-built spoolie, while LA Girl Featherlite Powder Brow Pencil combines a velvety matte powder formula with a built-in spoolie.

Choosing Your Eyebrow Pencil:

Choose a fine or ultra-fine tip when precision and individual-looking strokes are your priority. Triangular tips can help with both outlining and filling larger gaps, while powder-style pencils create a softer effect. Waterproof and long-wear options are also represented, including Benefit, Fenty Beauty and Maybelline formulas designed to resist smudging during wear.

Shade choices across the collection include blonde, grey, brunette, warm and cool browns, deep brown, black-brown and soft black, making it easier to select an eyebrow pencil that complements your natural brow and hair colour.